top of page

Lucy Letby Case: The Evans and Bohin Double Act and More Allegations of Inflicted Harm that Never Went Anywhere

9 hours ago
5 min read

by Peter Elston


The Crown Prosecution Service announced on January 20, 2026, that it would not bring a further 11 criminal charges in relation to nine babies against Lucy Letby after reviewing evidence submitted by Cheshire Police in July 2025. This blog draws on leaked disclosure documents to set out the suspicions cited by Drs Sandie Bohin and Dewi Evans in relation to 15 babies. The extent to which the nine babies on Cheshire Police's July 2025 charging application were among these 15 is not known but it is likely to be to a high degree.




It must be remembered that the prosecution in the Letby case will have understood the need to make their now-discredited case look watertight in the eyes of the jurors. This is akin to a magician ensuring a complicated trick looks real in the eyes of their audience. The difference of course is that a magician's audience will know that they did not actually see a human being being cut in half, they just don't know how the tricked worked. Otherwise, the analogy holds.


In my last blog I showed that lead police and prosecution medical expert Dewi Evans changed his opinion, either explicitly or implicitly, in relation to 30 out of 49 clinical events that he identified. I did this by drawing on leaked notes of meetings between Evans and Cheshire Police, and on his written witness statements (expert reports).


There is, however, more.


I have over the last three or so years compiled a database of 108 babies who in some way have been cited actively in relation to the criminal case against Letby (by actively I mean a specific examination, whether witness statements, a reference in a documentary, or otherwise). While the 30 aforementioned changes in opinion are essentially a subset of these 108 babies, most on the list form a separate subset. Source material includes police disclosure documents, BBC Panorama, and Freedom of Information responses.


I have been extremely careful with respect to patient confidentiality. As with my previous blog, this one includes a table of information relating to babies (see below). There are no babies' names, initials, dates of birth or other information such as birthweights and gestational ages at birth, even though many of the source documents include them. I have given each baby a number (from 1 to 108) and also, for the trial babies, the letter given to them (A to Q).


In many ways I need to be even more careful with the table in this blog than with the one in the last one. This is because the last blog related to the 31 Phase 1 babies appraised by Evans and co, and to some degree, however small, their parents may feel they have some sense of closure, whether because their babies' cases were put before a jury or because, in the case of the other 14, Cheshire Police will or should have explained things to them.


In the table in this blog, there are instances of suspicion of alleged inflicted harm in relation to 15 babies that were not charged. Only one of these was among the 31 babies appraised by Evans and co. in Phase 1. In other words, there are suspicions of inflicted harm in respect of 14 of the 77 "non Phase 1" babies.


The extent to which the nine babies on the rejected Phase 2 charging application are among these 14 is not clear. It is also not clear whether the aforementioned Phase 1 "non-charged" baby was part of the Phase 2 charging application.


This uncertainty, together with the large number of babies in the table, are the reasons I need to be even more careful with this article and the table therein. I have therefore been meticulous in ensuring that there is nothing that can identify the 91 non-indictment babies (14 non-charged Phase 1 babies plus 77 "non-Phase 1" babies) in the attached table.


At the same time, I feel strongly that the new information and findings set out in this article have a strong public interest element and should also be of interest to Letby's legal team. Furthermore, if parents wonder if their babies are among the 91 on the list (parents of the 17 indictment babies do not have this particular concern) they can send this article to Cheshire Police and ask them.


I cannot imagine the dreadful concerns that parents might still have as to whether their baby or babies were part of Cheshire Police's investigations. My sincere hope is that they see that I have struck a good balance between, on the one hand, ensuring confidentiality and, on the other, providing them with what may be useful information.


As for what I think are the key observations from the attached table, they are as follows:


  • The nine babies on the Phase 2 charging application are very likely to be among the allegations/suspicions of inflicted harm in relation to the 15 babies in the attached table. Many if not all these allegations appear very similar to those pertaining to the trial babies (insulin poisoning, NGT air, intravenous air, tampering, smothering, etc). And yet the Phase 1 application was accepted (by local CPS) and that relating to Phase 2 rejected (by national CPS). My question is, what are the legal implications of this difference?


  • While the 31 Phase 1 babies were selected either because they had died during the period of elevated mortality or by the treating paediatricians, a matrix was used for Phase 2. This was the subject of a disclosure application by Ben Myers during the trial, with judge Goss accepting prosecuting barrister Nick Johnson's answers that a) the matrix was not used with respect to the [Phase 1] indictment cases, and b) there was no material indicating whether Letby was not present at other incidents appraised. Myers had also asked whether the matrix had a "Letby present" criterion and, if so, what was its weighting. However, Phase 2 prosecution medical expert reports were written before the trial i.e. before Letby was found guilty. My question is, if there was a presumption of guilt before the trial applied in relation to the matrix and thus to Phase 2, what are the legal implications of this presumption being "carried forward" until after the trial?


  • I have only included extracts of witness statements that refer to the 15 allegations of inflicted harm. However, witness statements were written with respect to many of the 91 babies. In many cases it is hard (certainly for this non-medic) to discern differences between the medical circumstances of the 15 babies (as set out in the statements) and the others. Independent doctors should be engaged to appraise all the statements in order to opine as to why Evans and Bohin alleged harm in some cases but not others. This may help shed further light on the criteria used in the matrix.


  • There are instances of statements having been both disclosed and not disclosed to the defence. Why this is should be investigated.


  • There are many instances of "do not disclose" or "clearly do not disclose" (I don't know if there is an important difference). The related statements should be looked at to determine whether these decisions were correct i.e. whether there was a material non-disclosure issue.


  • As with Phase 1, there are many instances of Evans and Bohin "tag teaming", which brings into question the extent to which one's report in relation to a particular baby was independent of the other's. In other words, should the experts have done more than simply peer review.


  • Many of the entries are from a table in one of the BBC Panorama documentaries about Letby which pertain to hypoglycaemia and therefore to possible insulin action. These should be independently reviewed.


As with the last blog, I welcome comments with respect to any mistakes (whether in the text of this blog or the table); further observations that could/should be made; or legal and other expert opinion about the merit of my inferences.


Below is the table (click it then "save as image" or use this link - https://static.wixstatic.com/media/351877_fc494c7914164f09b71eb13d857cdd3e~mv2.jpeg).


Comments


Receive posts direct from Mephitis by email

Note: subscription to emails is not the same as membership of the site. In addition to emails, membership allows the posting of comments etc.  The membership area is here.

Thank you for subscribing 

SOCIAL

  • X

© 2024 by Mephitis

CONTACT

​

​Mephitis is based in London and will see any comments you append to posts, be thankful for them, and may very well respond to them, but if you’d like to contact them directly click here.

Mephitis_transparent.png
bottom of page